Explore Now Nature of equity in law: Expert And Legal Insight

Equity definition in law

Equity, derived from the Latin word “aequitas”, signifies fairness and justice. In legal terms, equity is a distinct body of law developed to mitigate the rigidity and insufficiency of the common law. Originating from the English Court of Chancery, equity represents a collection of principles and doctrines that supplement or override statutory and common law where necessary, intending to achieve just and ethical outcomes.

As legal historian John Selden remarked, equity was often seen as unpredictable, but it provided a flexible and conscience-driven path to justice when common law fell short. Over time, equity evolved into a system governed by structured principles, not merely the personal judgment of the chancellor.

Definitions by Legal Scholars

• Mainland: Equity consists of rules that would be administered by Courts of Equity if not merged by the Judicature Acts.
• Henry Levery Ulman: Equity is guided by conscience, not by written or customary law.
• Snell: Equity fills the gaps left by common law and enforces rights that are judicially recognized but previously unenforceable due to legal technicalities.

Nature and scope of equity In Law

The nature of equity lies in its ethical foundation. It aims to ensure justice where the strict rules of law may result in unfairness. It evolved to:

1. Enforce rights that are currently ignored by the common law.
2. Provide remedies beyond common law (e.g., injunction, specific performance).
3. Correct procedural defects in legal enforcement.

Equity is not based on morality alone; rather, it must be grounded in recognized equitable principles. Equity follows the law but adds a layer of conscience, ethics, and fairness.

General Principles of Equity (Maxims)

Some core equitable maxims that shape equity jurisprudence:

1. Equity will not suffer a wrong without a remedy – Justice must be actionable.
2. Equity follows the law – Equity supplements but does not override law.
3. He who seeks equity must do equity – Fairness must be mutual.
4. Delay defeats equity – Rights must be pursued diligently.
5. Equity delights in equality – Equity aims for proportional fairness.
6. Where equities are equal, the first in time prevails – Earlier equitable interest gets priority.
7. Legal estate prevails over equitable estate – Statutory/legal title overrides equitable claims. 

Application of Equity in Bangladesh Law

Bangladesh’s legal system incorporates equitable principles extensively, particularly through statutes modeled after English law. However, their application is subject to the social, cultural, and statutory framework of Bangladesh.

Key Statutes Incorporating Equitable Principles:

• Specific Relief Act, 1877
  • Injunctions, rectification, cancellation, specific performance of contracts.
• Trust Act, 1882
  • Principles related to fiduciary obligations, trust formation, and duties of trustees.
• Contract Act, 1872
  • Provisions related to undue influence, compensation, and equity-based remedies (Sections 64, 65).
• Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Includes maxims like:
    • Where equities are equal, first in time prevails (Sections 48, 78, 79)
    • Legal estate prevails over equitable estate (Sections 40, 78)
    • Compensation for improvements made in good faith (Section 51)
    • Doctrine of election (Section 35)

Related Read: Barristers in Bangladesh
Related Read: Criminal Lawyer in Bangladesh

Remedies in Equity

Equity provides remedies where monetary compensation is inadequate. These include:

• Injunctions
• Specific performance
• Rescission
• Rectification
• Equitable estoppel
• Constructive trusts

Equitable remedies are discretionary, and the claimant must come to court with clean hands, having acted in good faith.

Doctrine of Election

This doctrine holds that a person cannot accept and reject the same instrument. If a person is offered a benefit under a will or contract but must surrender their own rights for it, they must choose (elect) to accept or decline the whole instrument. The doctrine promotes fairness and consistency in legal dealings.

Influence of Equity on the Constitution of Bangladesh

• Article 19(1) of the Constitution incorporates principles of equity, emphasizing justice and fairness in state policies. 
• The inherent powers of the courts under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure also empower judges to do complete justice, reflecting equity’s spirit. 

Limitations of English Equity in Bangladesh

While Bangladesh law has adopted many equitable principles, not all have been incorporated:

• Doctrine of Satisfaction and Ademption are not recognized. 
• Legal and equitable estates are not distinguished—unlike England. 
• Rights of redemption are legal, not equitable, in Bangladesh. 

Conclusion

Equity in Bangladesh plays a pivotal role in ensuring justice beyond the constraints of strict legal rules. It complements the common law by providing flexible, conscience-based remedies that prevent unfair outcomes.

Although rooted in English law, Bangladesh applies equity according to local values, usage, and statutory frameworks. Equity ensures that justice is not only done but seen to be done, bridging the gap between law and fairness.