BAD CHARACTER EVIDENCE

Introduction The admissibility of bad character evidence in criminal proceedings is governed by Part 11 Criminal Justice Act 2003 (Sections 98 -113), section 99 of which abolished the existing common law rules. The only qualification to the abolition of the common law rules is ...

Read More

WHAT IS WRONG WITH CHARACTER EVIDENCE? PART 4

Conclusion: Unresolved Issues I have argued that the current character evidence rule is an unstable halfway house between (i) a legal regime that altogether prohibits the use of character to show the doing of an act and (ii) a system ...

Read More

WHAT IS WRONG WITH CHARACTER EVIDENCE? PART 3

The Prohibition Against Circumstantial Character Evidence: Appearance and Reality The practice of using information about the human psyche as evidence in criminal trials has a long pedigree in America. Long before legal scholars of evidence generally acknowledged the practice, trial ...

Read More

WHAT IS WRONG WITH CHARACTER EVIDENCE? PART 2

Human Character and Human Autonomy The Notion of Autonomy in General Although the concept of human autonomy plays a prominent role in fields such as substantive criminal law,[1] that concept rarely figures in discussions of the character evidence rule [2] ...

Read More

WHAT IS WRONG WITH CHARACTER EVIDENCE? PART 1

By Peter tillers [1] Introduction: Rethinking the Riddle of the Character Evidence Rule The rule barring the use of character to show conduct—the “character evidence rule”—has undergone significant erosion in recent years. The rule also has been subjected to withering criticism. ...

Read More

EFFECT OF BAD CHARACTER EVIDENCE ON JURIES

Introduction: The Criminal Justice Act 2003 (CJA) was introduced to allow more defendants’ bad character evidence to be introduced to juries, in contrast to what was allowed before, under previous law. Defendants or witnesses in a criminal case will often ...

Read More

CUSTOMIZING EMPLOYMENT ARBITRATION, PART 3

Erin O'Hara O'Connor Florida State University College of Law Kenneth J. Martin Randall S. Thomas Customizing Employment Arbitration Table 9 Regression Results (/►VALUES IN PARENTHESES) CARVEDUM = 1 if contract includes at least one carveout, o if there are no ...

Read More

CUSTOMIZING EMPLOYMENT ARBITRATION, PART 2

Erin O'Hara O'Connor Florida State University College of Law Kenneth J. Martin Randall S. Thomas III. Univariate Analysis We begin our empirical analysis with a description of our data- collection procedure and an overview of the prevalence of arbitration clauses ...

Read More